Project Wonderful Review

Aside: I wrote this review years ago, however all of the information is still accurate in 2016.

A month ago I began running ads from a service called Project Wonderful. Their site is here. In the past I had tried Google Adsense but I wasn’t happy with the ads that were being delivered to the blog. Adsense is supposed to deliver contextual ads but I rarely found that to be the case. The result was basically earning next to nothing from Google. Nobody wants to click ads for online universities and crap like that. When you have a niche market as us 40K and wargaming blogs do, you need ads that are relevant if there’s any hope of actually getting something out of putting the ads on your site.

That’s how I discovered Project Wonderful. A co-worker of mine mentioned hearing about it when I said I was debating putting Adsense back on my blog. I checked it out and quickly signed up then began playing around with it. The thing I really like the most with Project Wonderful is their approach to advertising. I could turn this into a huge article about all the differences with them and Adsense but I’ll keep it brief and leave it up to you to check it out if I piqué your interest.

Publishers

The largest difference is how advertisers work with publishers (those who put ads on their sites). As a publisher you create ad boxes which is you telling advertisers what spots you have available on your site to advertise on. Unlike Adsense where ads just start showing up once you’ve done that, instead advertisers bid on your ad boxes and the winner gets their ad shown on your site. The way advertisers bid is to say they are willing to pay $X a day to advertise in a particular ad box. So unlike Adsense where you get paid based on a click/view ratio, advertisers pay you straight up for advertising on your site each day, not a rate based on clicks and views. If someone runs an ad with me and nobody clicks it I still get the rate they said they’d pay me for advertising for the day. Google doesn’t do that. In addition, because of this difference, there’s no concern about clicking on the ads shown on your site. I’m not getting paid per-click so if I find an ad interesting that’s being shown on my site then I’ll click it. Google frowns on that with Adsense.

Publishers have control over ads placed on their site. If you want you can require all ads wanting to be placed with you be approved by you before beginning. There’s also some options for the type of ads. If you don’t want NSFW ads on your site then you don’t have to accept them and that’s a hands-off option, you don’t have to manually decline them.

Advertisers

As an advertiser you can find cheap ad placement, like $0 cheap. Publishers can set a minimum required to advertise with them but a vast majority do not set a minimum and so you can run ads on their site for free. It requires some manual labor to place free ads, not a lot though. There’s also the ability to create a campaign for advertising. In short, you define your criteria for sites you’d like to advertise on. It can be the type of site, sites matching a particular description, by traffic, etc. You then set up bidding parameters and say you’re willing to spend $X a day on advertising and you have a maximum budget of $Y. The campaign will automatically make bids for you based on the criteria you’ve set up and you just sit back and watch the clicks come through.

Related Reading  Continued Progress on All Fronts

An example. I created a campaign targeting gamers and set a daily expense limit of 20 cents and a maximum budget of $1. Once the $1 ran out the campaign stopped. My ads were shown 23,651 times and received 13 clicks. I won’t get into all the other metrics but it didn’t do too poorly though it could have been better. Improving how many clicks my campaign gets will come down to my targeting of sites I advertise on, my criteria, as well as my ads themselves. Regardless, I thought it was a good experiment and I only spent $1, no complaints.

Full Ad Control

That’s something I really like about Project Wonderful, you’re in full control of everything from the ads that run on your site to the ads you place and how much, or how little, you’re willing to spend. There really isn’t an aspect that you don’t have a say over. The result of all this is the type of people placing ads tend to be the sort of demographic that works with a wargaming blog. Project Wonderful gained huge ground from web comics. Web comics are easily the largest category of people running ads through them. Gamers of various types are another large market. Basically, it’s people like you and I who are placing ads and showing those ads.

Project Wonderful Profits

Now, the final bit that some of you bloggers are likely curious about, the profits. When I ran Adsense the last time out I ran it for a month. In that month I made $1.59. With Project Wonderful in a month I’ve made $1.64. We’re not talking a huge difference in profits obviously but it can only go up from here. That was my first month out with Project Wonderful and as my blog continues to grow and gain more readers so too will I gain more wiling to advertise on here and spend more money to do so. For those of you will much larger followings than I you will inevitably do much better. I’m not one for sharing my stats and so I won’t, but I know some of you who read this blog have a larger readership than I do.

In conclusion, if you’re considering trying to monetize your blog then I highly suggest checking out Project Wonderful.

Aside: Those amounts mentioned above were in 2011. In 2016 I have tried Project Wonderful, as well as in 2015, a few times, but never had any real success with it. My traffic here is significantly higher than in 2011, yet I was only making around 3 cents a day with Project Wonderful. It just seems like nobody is willing to pay much to advertise on the sites there any longer. I now rely on Adsense as my primary means of advertising income, and Project Wonderful doesn’t even come close to it any longer.

  • Anonymous

    Interesting.  The taboo click was one of the main reasons I didn’t like adsense. 

    • Same here. Hell, most of the money I had made with Adsense was me doing just that despite it being frowned upon. So even the comparison I made isn’t accurate when you take that into account.

  • chronicler_Isiah

    I use Project Wonderful on my site to host ads to gain a (little bit) of income – so I am a publisher.

    My experience is that you aren’t going to make an awful lot of money as a publisher because most of the advertisers who use PW are small and don’t have the money top spend. Or, are just after advertising for free! But why should they? Set a minimum ad price even if it’s very low.

    Additionally I’ve found that despite PW vetting potential publisher sites (like mine) for quality of design etc – they don’t seem to vet advertisers’ ads or sites in the same way (?).

    So as far as ads that get placed on your site – expect either kitsch, or just poorly-designed ads, that in a lot of cases link to similarly poorly-designed websites. This to the detriment of both the look and reputation of your own site.

    That said – unlike other advertising models, the bidding is fun and at least you will get some kind of income if only a small one.

    • I’ve since given up on PW. I liked the atmosphere of “We’re here for the little guy,” but that only goes so far. I did like how things worked but in the end the money just wasn’t there. If I’m going to run ads then I may as well make something from it. I’ve made more in a single day with Adsense than an entire month with PW; hard to argue with results.

      • I have been screwing around with every ad scheme there is. AdSense, Project Wonderful, and now supportingads. I think that the niche nature of the content makes it really hard to end up with ads that are targeted to your readers. AdSense seems to be the “best” earner; content is king, but it doesn’t help with the ads.

  • I am just thinking about joining Project Wonderful after leaving an ad network which served malware ads on my website. Had somebody a problem with malware when using Project Wonderful?

    • In all my years of using Project Wonderful, I have never had any issues with Malware.

      • Thanks! I have joined them about one month ago and so far everything is ok. Seems to be a good alternative to the traditional advertising networks.

        • The money was never great for me, but it is nice to show ads from other small blogs; people just like me.

          • Well, I do not expect too much but it is great to be able to monetize a new website. I have launched a web where I offer my photos for free and I am thinking about opening the website for other photographers in the future and offer revenue sharing. So it is great to have some numbers to know how CPM is realistic.

            • That’s a great idea. Best of luck with it.

%d bloggers like this: